A third of persistently absent Year 10–11 pupils end up NEET: what the Milburn review says about attendance
The Milburn review on young people’s employment was published on 17 November. What it says about school attendance, why the government links persistent absence to NEET, and what teachers and parents can do.
Alan Milburn’s review of young people’s employment was published on 17 November, and one line in the coverage has caught the attention of schools and parents: the government estimates that around a third of pupils who are persistently absent in Years 10 and 11 in England go on to be not in education, employment or training, known as NEET. The review itself calls for what it describes as a “complete system reset” to help 440,000 young people into work. Attendance is one part of the picture, and it is worth reading the wider point carefully before drawing conclusions.
This article sets out what the review says, what the attendance figure does and does not show, and what a science department or a parent can do this term without waiting for national policy to change.
What the review says
The review argues that the current arrangements for education, employment and support are not working well enough for young people. It proposes a “complete system reset”, and it calls for reform across education, employment and social support. Its aim is to bring 440,000 young people into work.
The scale of the problem is set out in the coverage. Around one million people aged 16 to 24 are NEET. The proposals cover education, employment and social support together, which is why school attendance appears in the discussion at all.
Be careful with the detail. The review’s headline call is for a “complete system reset”. Any specific measure, timetable or budget that you read elsewhere should be checked against the review text itself before you rely on it.
The attendance figure, and what it does not show
The figure about persistent absence is the government’s estimate, and it is the one that has been widely reported. Around a third of pupils who are persistently absent in Years 10 and 11 in England are thought to go on to be NEET.
It is a useful warning, but it is not a prediction about any individual child. A figure for a group cannot tell you what will happen to one pupil. What it does point to is a link between two patterns: pupils who are persistently absent in the later years of secondary school are, on the government’s estimate, a group at real risk of moving into NEET afterwards.
That is a reason to take attendance seriously in the final years of school, not a reason to label any child. The review’s point is about the system as a whole, and the most useful response from a school is to look at its own pupils and the routes they have.
Why attendance matters in science lessons
Science is a subject that builds on itself. A missed practical, a skipped unit on electricity or a gap in the cell biology sequence can make the next topic harder to follow. For pupils in Years 10 and 11, who are working towards GCSEs, a run of missed lessons can quickly turn into a sense that the course is no longer manageable.
Science departments can do a few things that help pupils stay in lessons.
- Make the first five minutes count. A short starter with a clear question gives a reason to arrive on time and gets everyone into the room.
- Use practicals that are easy to join. A pupil who has missed a week can still take part in a short demonstration or a card sort.
- Keep a quick record of what was covered. A simple shared summary of each lesson lets a returning pupil catch up without feeling exposed.
- Talk to the pupil, not just about them. Ask what is getting in the way, and what would help. The answer is often practical: transport, caring duties, anxiety about a subject or a clash with work.
None of these steps comes from the review. They are sensible classroom habits that many teachers already use, and they are worth keeping in mind while the wider policy debate continues.
Working with parents and carers
Parents and carers often notice a change in attendance before the school does, or the other way round. A calm, early conversation is far more useful than a letter after the fact. Share what you have seen in lessons, ask what has changed at home, and agree one or two steps that the pupil can manage.
For a parent who is worried about a child’s attendance, the most useful question is simple: what would make it easier to come in? Ask the school about support in place, and whether there is a named person to talk to. Keep notes of what is agreed, so that everyone can see progress over the next few weeks.
What to do this term
If you are a teacher, pick one practical habit from the list above and try it for a fortnight. Track whether returning pupils settle more quickly. If you are a parent, ask the school for a clear picture of your child’s attendance and what support is available.
Whatever your role, avoid treating a figure as a verdict on a child. A third is a striking number, but the review’s point is about the system, and the answer lies in the detail of individual pupils.
If you are planning lessons that bring pupils back into the room, our guide to science games in the classroom has ideas that work well for mixed groups. A short Christmas science quiz for the last lesson of term is another option for the final week before the break.
Key points
- The Milburn review on young people’s employment was published on 17 November. It calls for a “complete system reset” to help 440,000 young people into work.
- Around one million people aged 16 to 24 are NEET.
- The government estimates that about a third of pupils who are persistently absent in Years 10 and 11 in England later become NEET.
- The figure is a link across a system, not a prediction about any individual child.
- Classroom habits, early conversations with families and practical support all matter more than labels.
- Check the review text before relying on any specific measure that is reported elsewhere.
For more classroom material, browse the resource catalogue by key stage, or get in touch if you want to submit something you have built yourself.
Made something good? Send it in.
The bank only ever grew because teachers and trainees shared what they had built for their own classes. If you have a worksheet, a card sort or a starter presentation that works, pass it on.